Rent a dinner venue in Shelter Island, NY

Discover thousands of unique dinner venues for rent perfect for your event.

Enter your activity
Shelter Island, NY, United States

How dinner party venues work on Peerspace

Peerspace is the easiest way to book unique venues for dinners. We also have spaces for productions and meetings.

Discover Spaces

Unique venues

Every day we uncover new, creative spaces perfect for your dinner party — from neighborhood galleries to hidden rooftops, and beyond.

Honest pricing

Our spaces are priced to fit your budget. Hire by the hour for your dinner without worrying about hidden fees.

Smooth bookings

No more messy contracts. We build the tools to make hiring out a space for your dinner party as easy as the click of a button.

Popular dinner venues

Explore all of our dinner venues in Shelter Island. See All ›
from$400/hr
Elegant Home, Vaulted Ceiling, Black & White Marble Check Floor on Half Acre

Shelter Island, NY

Venue capacity icon70

House

...long drapes, antique rugs, unique light fixtures, vintage 1983 two door white mercedes 380SL, fenced in property area for animals, modern stainless kitchen, outdoor black & white shed...
...
from$775/hr
Rustic Home | 5074

Shelter Island, NY

Venue capacity icon50

House

...home conveniently located in Shelter Island, New York. Please inquire via Peerspace messaging if you have any questions or are interested. Features: • Kitchen • Natural Light • Swimming Pool Available for: • Photo/Film Shoot • Content Creation/Blogging/Youtube Videos • Podcasts/Interviews • Movies/Films • Tik Tok Videos/Social Media...
...
from$1,500/hr
Bright and Airy Contemporary Home | 5296

3.6 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Venue capacity icon50

House

...contemporary home conveniently located in Greenport, New York. Please inquire via Peerspace messaging if you have any questions or are interested. Features: • Kitchen • Natural Light • Backyard Available for: • Photo/Film Shoot • Content Creation/Blogging/Youtube Videos • Podcasts/Interviews • Movies/Films • Tik Tok Videos/Social Media...
...
from$980/hr
5000 sqft Ultramodern Masterpiece House in Nature

5.6 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Venue capacity icon60

Residence

...dock ✓ Portable speaker ✓ Thermostats in all living spaces (temperature-controlled rooms) ☒ No projectors, but we can coordinate all AV/tech for your booking Kitchen ✓ White kitchen with built-in power plugs and direct outdoor access (outdoor dining area) ✓ Stove ✓ Oven ✓ Coffee machine ✓ Fridge ✓ Outdoor: 1 rustic...
...
from$750/hr
Exotic luxury Mansion in East Hamptons

6.2 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Venue capacity icon70

Mansion

...As you step inside, the spacious living areas are bathed in natural light, creating a warm and inviting ambiance. The chef's kitchen features top-of-the-line appliances and sleek countertops, perfect for culinary enthusiasts. Upstairs, you'll find the serene bedrooms offering...
...
from$400/hr
North Fork mid-century ranch between beaches and vineyards

6.3 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Venue capacity icon8

Ranch Home

...relax, cozy, wabi-sabi vibe and beautiful natural light throughout. It offers an open plan living dining area with a fully equipped kitchen and counter as well as 2 bedrooms, an office/den and 2 bathrooms. Located on a secluded park-like setting of over...
...
from$250/hr
Chic Hamptons House with Pool

6.8 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Venue capacity icon75

House

...Chic Hamptons house is a newly constructed 1,000 square foot two-bed, two-bath guest-house with a full kitchen and washer/dryer. The living room and kitchen are separated from the bedrooms and bathrooms by a sliding door providing privacy for talent holding if...
...
from$1,000/hr
Designer Modern East Hampton Home

7.3 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Venue capacity icon50

House

...open-concept great room with fireplace is filled with light from french door egress and seamlessly flows into a luxe eat-in kitchen with elegant, natural-hued custom cabinets and Silestone countertops. The main level en-suite primary is accented by brushed metal with dual...
...
from$1,250/hr
2 Barns in a beautiful property with horses in Water Mill, Hamptons New York

7.6 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Venue capacity icon120

Bayfront Home

...Water Mill, Hamptons New York. Lots of character and style. Ideal for an event or a film or photoshoot. We hosted large dinner parties inside the barn in the past. Beautiful garden full of flowers, 2 Barns, one large pond, swimming pool, horses, 12 acres...
...

Frequently Asked Questions



Pricing and popularity information in this section is based on proprietary data from bookings made on Peerspace from 2016-2024.

Reviews for dinner venues

Leah J.
Beautiful Shangrila Full Home in Westchester, NY 45 min from nyc
space was absolutely beautiful! Her property provides so many different spaces to film. We filmed primarily outside for two days and also in the kitchen. Everything went so smoothly, and Osi was very quick to respond to any and all questions. She was very accommodating. The location is very convenient...
Susanne C.
Large & Bright Designer Showroom w/ Tall Ceilings
beautiful, clean, and bright! Naz might be one of the nicest humans you will ever meet. She was kind and attentive to our needs. Kitchen displays are exquisite, even nicer in person...
Tim M.
Large & Bright Designer Showroom w/ Tall Ceilings
Great spot and location, multiple kitchen setups allows you to jump from kitchen to kitchen. Extremely easy load-in through front door with parking right there, and hosts were very accommodating and friendly from start to finish...
Lasherelle M.
Artistic, Inspiring Space-Heart of Garden City,NY
Great space for a small group dinner
Dana C.
Charming renovated Carriage House
Great yard space and adorable kitchen. Perfect house for our shoot
Shauna F.
Events On The Main Venue with amazing private yard space
The Staff was amazing, they did an awesome job for my daughter and niece’s college graduation brunch. I was overjoyed and happy with my experience. Will definitely use again...
Austin W.
The Board Room - Downtown in the heart of New Haven's 9th square!
alot of parking and lunch spots. Welcoming staff and great layout for our offsite and time. Facilities are in great condition, clean bathrooms and kitchen available for breakfast/snacks during our sessions. Would recommend and book again...
Jazzmene L.
Our Amazing Lounge Is The Perfect Venue For Your Next Event!
went around not going through the party at all. I’m so pleased and can’t wait to have my next event there. The kitchen was amazing to have there was ice and water accessible through the fridge. There was ample space for items to be put in the fridge...