16 Best Lake Houses for Rent in New Albany, OH | Peerspace

How lake houses work on Peerspace

Peerspace is the easiest way to book unique spaces for meetings, events, film, and photo shoots.

Discover Spaces

The most locations

Every day we uncover new, creative spaces — from mid-century homes to creative studios, and beyond.

Professional hosts

Our network of helpful hosts respond quickly, and are well-versed in accommodating film and photo shoots.

Book by the hour

Only pay for what you need. Pay by the hour without worrying about hidden fees or overtime.

Discover Spaces

Popular lake houses

Explore all of our lake houses in New Albany. See All ›

Parker Reserve

The New Albany Country Club, OH

5.0 (7)

25 guests

Parker Reserve. This property offers an exquisite blend of luxury and nature, delivering an

From

$200

/hr

6 hr min

Dream Away Homes

5.3 miles from New Albany, OH

5.0 (1)

20 guests

Dream Away Homes. Discover a serene and versatile filming and photoshoot location just

From

$145

/hr

6 hr min

Parker Reserve

Serving the New Albany, OH area

5.0 (2)

20 guests

Parker Reserve. This A Frame is perfect for a range of activities—whether you’re seeking

From

$125

/hr

6 hr min

Counterbalance Brewing

Serving the New Albany, OH area

5.0 (1)

100 guests

Counterbalance Brewing. The Henderson House is a beautifully preserved 1859 brick farmhouse

From

$75

/hr

1 hr min

Stunning Luxury Home | Private Acre Yard | Fire Pit

Plain View Farms, New Albany, OH

5.0 (2)

20 guests

Step into Wellbeing Escape – Your Ideal Canvas for Cinematic Brilliance! Unveil the magic

From

$175

/hr

3 hr min

Modern Luxury Content House | Natural Light, Designer Kitchen + Outdoor Lounge

Tidewater at New Albany, OH

5.0 (1)

25 guests

A modern luxury farmhouse designed as a multi set content house with natural light, high

From

$250

/hr

3 hr min

Serenity On Seven Acres- Luxurious Log Cabin

5.6 miles from New Albany, OH

30 guests

Nestled in the heart of Johnstown, Ohio, this exquisite 4,500 sqft log cabin is a

From

$100

/hr

2 hr min

Historical Downtown Home with Upscale, Vintage Charm

6.7 miles from New Albany, OH

5.0 (1)

20 guests

Discover the charm of this unique historic home, a versatile space designed for a range

From

$150

/hr

3 hr min

1887 Artsy Vintage Home

Serving the New Albany, OH area

5.0 (2)

25 guests

My house was built in 1887 and had retained much of its original character. There is a

From

$85

/hr

2 hr min

Cool and Modern Family Home

Serving the New Albany, OH area

5.0 (2)

50 guests

This is a 4 level split level home (over 3,000 sq ft) with abundant light and modern and

From

$120

/hr

6 hr min

Stylish Private Guesthouse

Serving the New Albany, OH area

5.0 (5)

20 guests

A private guesthouse in the heart of historic downtown Dublin that allows you the

From

$150

/hr

4 hr min

Modern stylish home with expansive outdoor living and pool

Serving the New Albany, OH area

5.0 (2)

25 guests

This home has endless possibilities for photo shoots. Expensive first floor with tons of

From

$500

/hr

4 hr min

Traditional home on Darby Creek

Serving the New Albany, OH area

5.0 (3)

35 guests

The home is a traditional ranch with nearly 4,000 sq ft of living space. The home has

From

$200

/hr

4 hr min

Picturesque tree lined home on a pond with a swimming pool, open concept floor plan, and modern decor.

Serving the New Albany, OH area

5.0 (2)

50 guests

Picturesque tree lined home on a pond with a swimming pool, open concept floor plan, and

From

$200

/hr

4 hr min

House with Open Kitchen, Free Parking, WiFi & Natural Light

Serving the New Albany, OH area

5.0 (1)

20 guests

A customized builder grade home with upgraded fixtures, hardware and flooring throughout

From

$75

/hr

3 hr min

Cozy Cottage Escape

Serving the New Albany, OH area

5.0 (1)

14 guests

Discover the enchantment of our woodland retreat, nestled amidst towering trees. This

From

$75

/hr

2 hr min

Frequently Asked Questions

Pricing and popularity information in this section is based on proprietary Peerspace booking data, reflecting recent booking activity and the latest data available through September 2026.

How much does a lake house cost to rent in New Albany?

Lake houses in New Albany average $223 per hour to rent, but it’s easy to spend less or more depending on what you’re looking for. For a space on the smaller side, expect to spend closer to $128, whereas larger venues run about $132 per hour.

$128/hr$132/hr

How long do people rent lake houses in New Albany?

Most lake houses are scheduled for 3 hours, with 7 people in attendance. You’ll find the most Lake Houses starting between 11:00 AM and 12:00 PM.

8:00 AM3:00 PM

How popular are lake houses in New Albany?

Our local hosts have welcomed 268 people into their lake houses with reviews averaging 5 stars. 100% of guests said they'd book again.

Similar searches in New Albany, OH

Updated August 23, 2026Our data is refreshed in real time using booking trends, verified guest reviews, and direct partner updates — with additional quality checks from our team.