Find your creative space in Shelter Island, NY

Book thousands of unique spaces directly from Shelter Island hosts.

Enter your activity
Shelter Island, NY, United States
  1. Home
  2. Locations
  3. Shelter Island, NY

Why Peerspace?

Unique spaces

Every day we uncover new, creative spaces — from neighborhood galleries to hidden rooftops, and beyond.

Honest pricing

Our spaces are priced to fit your budget. Pay by the hour without worrying about hidden fees.

Smooth bookings

No more messy contracts. We build the tools to make booking a space as easy as the click of a button.

Shelter Island Event Spaces

From rooftop parties to private dining, explore event spaces in Shelter Island built for any occasion.

5000 sqft Ultramodern Masterpiece House in Nature

Noyack, New York, NY

300 guests

From 
$1,450
/hr
6 hr min

East Hampton Estate with Pool, Spa & Tennis Court

East Hampton, East Hamptons, NY

50 guests

From 
$3,500
/hr
4 hr min

Retro Space Age Cafe

North Fork, Peconic, NY

20 guests

From 
$400
/hr
2 hr min

Classic and chic Hamptons Home

East Hampton, NY

40 guests

From 
$1,000
/hr
5 hr min

19 Century Farm House in Hamptons

East Hampton, Amagansett, NY

40 guests

From 
$350
/hr
4 hr min

Luminous White 3-Story Open Oasis Home in Amangasett

East Hampton, Amgansett, NY

60 guests

From 
$615
/hr
6 hr min

Nature-Inspired Retreat in Westhampton Beach

Southampton, westhampton beach, NY

150 guests

From 
$500
/hr
4 hr min

Lavender field and orchard with views for miles

Riverhead, NY

250 guests

From 
$100
/hr
5 hr min
See all listings

Shelter Island Creative Spaces

Find Shelter Island studios and creative spaces built for photo shoots, video production, content creation, and more.

Unique 1869 Church, Converted to a Home

North Fork, Greenport, NY

30 guests

From 
$95
/hr
4 hr min

Rustic 1970s Cabin in the East Hampton Woods

East Hampton, NY

12 guests

From 
$250
/hr
4 hr min

Architectural Digest Featured Bali-Inspired Hamptons Estate`

East Hampton, East Hamptons, NY

10 guests

From 
$650
/hr
4 hr min

Luxury Hamptons Estate with Pool Near Georgica Beach

East Hampton, Wainscot, NY

10 guests

From 
$450
/hr
4 hr min

Gorgeous new home on the beach With STUNNING views of the LI Sound and vivid colorful sunsets

North Fork, Peconic, NY

30 guests

From 
$220
/hr
4 hr min

East Hampton Home with Heated Pool & One-Acre Setting

East Hampton, East Hamptons, NY

42 guests

From 
$2,000
/hr
5 hr min

Contemporary East Hampton Home

east hampton, NY

5.0 (1)

45 guests

From 
$600
/hr
2 hr min

Classic Hamptons Home with Dramatic Views of Pond on a Private Street

Bridgehampton, NY

5.0 (2)

30 guests

From 
$800
/hr
7 hr min
See all listings

Shelter Island Off Site

East Hampton Estate with Pool, Spa & Tennis Court

East Hampton, East Hamptons, NY

48 guests

From 
$2,497
/hr
4 hr min

5000 sqft Ultramodern Masterpiece House in Nature

Noyack, New York, NY

300 guests

From 
$925
/hr
6 hr min

East Hampton Home with Heated Pool & One-Acre Setting

East Hampton, East Hamptons, NY

30 guests

From 
$2,350
/hr
2 hr min

Luminous White 3-Story Open Retreat Oasis Home in Amangasett

East Hampton, Amgansett, NY

45 guests

From 
$400
/hr
8 hr min

Classic and chic Hamptons Home

East Hampton, NY

40 guests

From 
$500
/hr
4 hr min

Private Beach Bungalow

East Lyme, Niantic, CT

15 guests

From 
$125
/hr
4 hr min

Luxurious Hamptons Beach Heated Pool Wineries

Southampton, Qougue, NY

10 guests

From 
$550
/hr
3 hr min

Nature-Inspired Retreat in Westhampton Beach

Southampton, westhampton beach, NY

40 guests

From 
$148
/hr
3 hr min
See all listings

Popular Activities

Updated February 19, 2026Our data is refreshed in real time using booking trends, verified guest reviews, and direct partner updates — with additional quality checks from our team.