22 Best Houses for Rent in Highland Lake, NY | Peerspace

How homes work on Peerspace

Peerspace is the easiest way to book unique for all kinds of productions including photo shoots, film shoots and music videos. We also have spaces for meetings and events.

The most locations

Every day we uncover new, inspirational spaces, including homes, perfect for your activity.

Professional hosts

Our network of helpful hosts respond quickly, and are well-versed in accommodating all types of productions, including film and photo shoots.

Hire by the hour

Only pay for what you need. Pay by the hour for your home location without worrying about hidden fees or overtime.

Popular houses

Highland Lake Estate

Highland, Highland Lake, NY

250 guests

From

$399

/hr

2 hr min

Historic 1850 Schoolhouse in Catskill Mountains Overlooking Delaware River

10 guests

From

$400

/hr

4 hr min

Cottage with Outdoor deck and half acre peaceful backyard

Lumberland, Glen Spey, NY

25 guests

From

$150

/hr

3 hr min

Tudor Stone House with River and Forest

Tusten, Narrowsburg, NY

40 guests

From

$200

/hr

4 hr min

Modern chateau in a 100% natural forest setting

100 guests

From

$750

/hr

2 hr min

Spacious Log Cabin Retreat with Natural Light, Open Layout and Forest Views

Lumberland, Glen Spey, NY

15 guests

From

$175

/hr

4 hr min

Private Manor With Victorian Era Inn, Barn Style Event Hall, Craftsman Bungalow, Lake, Barn, and 120 private acres

Deerpark, Sparrow Bush, NY

143 guests

From

$300

/hr

5 hr min

Lakeside Lodge with Studio Apartment

Thompson, Monticello, NY

25 guests

From

$250

/hr

4 hr min

Modern House with Art Pavilion

Bethel, White Lake, NY

10 guests

From

$300

/hr

3 hr min

Country Side, Rustic, Laid-Back

Tusten, Narrowsburg, NY

5.0 (1)

248 guests

From

$95

/hr

6 hr min

Modern Farmhouse in the Catskills

Narrowsburg, NY

50 guests

From

$250

/hr

8 hr min

Modern Architectural Black Barn Retreat on 10 Acres of Forested Land

Bethel, Jeffersonville, NY

50 guests

From

$600

/hr

4 hr min

Upstate Modern Classic

Bethel, Swan Lake, NY

10 guests

From

$300

/hr

8 hr min

Modern Cabin in the woods with stunnings views and open space, 14 acres

Callicoon, Jeffersonville, NY

15 guests

From

$125

/hr

1 hr min

7-Acre Modern Estate w/ Saltwater Pool & Private Studio

Lehman Township, Bushkill, PA

250 guests

From

$850

/hr

8 hr min

Quiet, secluded Poconos house with hot tub!

10 guests

From

$100

/hr

8 hr min

Country Home with Beautiful Views near Livingston Manor

25 guests

From

$75

/hr

4 hr min

1840s Farmhouse with Original Details

Fremont, Freemont Center, NY

5 guests

From

$75

/hr

2 hr min

Spacious home in the Catskill Mountains: Natural light & Entertaining space

Callicoon, Livingston Manor, NY

70 guests

From

$375

/hr

10 hr min

Upstate NY Luxury Estate with Pool, Padel Court & Scenic Views

Minisink, New York, NY

20 guests

From

$300

/hr

4 hr min

Victorian Luxury In The Catskills

Fremont, hankins, NY

15 guests

From

$750

/hr

6 hr min

Luxe & Modern farmhouse

Callicoon, Livingston Manor, NY

7 guests

From

$250

/hr

4 hr min

Similar searches in Highland Lake, NY

Updated October 25, 2026Our data is refreshed in real time using booking trends, verified guest reviews, and direct partner updates — with additional quality checks from our team.