The 8 Best Caterers in Pittsburgh

From Heinz to Hershey, Pennsylvania is a hotspot for some of America’s most iconic foods. But when it comes time to host your own event in Pittsburgh, what kinds of foods should you serve? Well, that depends on the theme of your event and the venue you choose. You’ll find dozens of memorable event spaces available for rent on Peerspace — many of them with large backyards and kitchens that chefs and caterers will love. Whether you’re hosting a formal or casual affair, choose one of these great caterers in Pittsburgh to deliver a unique menu to any venue!

1. Have a memorable night out with the Fluted Mushroom

For a traditional catering company offering gourmet dishes with an elegant style, check out the Fluted Mushroom. They provide full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and other occasions. This family-run company has been around since 1972, making them a reliable pick for a formal reception at a convention center or banquet hall. You can host your event at their house venue, which seats up to 500 guests, or use Peerspace to choose a suitable venue of your own. They also offer options for corporate catering, such as lunch boxes and buffets.

2. Enjoy seasonal menus from Bistro to Go

Bistro to Go is a local Pittsburgh cafe that offers a bistro-style menu for full service catering and pickup options. Their menus include breakfast, appetizers, and classic mains, including plenty of vegan and vegetarian options to suit any diet. They also have seasonal menus for every holiday you can think of, from Mardi Gras to Oktoberfest, and, of course, Easter and Thanksgiving. This is a particular great caterer in Pittsburgh for holiday parties.

3. Line up a caterer with the Peerspace Concierge

If you’re wondering which caterer in Pittsburgh is the best fit for your event space, why not give the Peerspace Concierge a call and get their professional opinion? Since each venue listed on Peerspace has its own combination of amenities, it makes sense to choose a caterer who can make the best use of the space and will have a sufficient staging area to work with.

For example, this unique meeting space with a full kitchen is perfect for a light corporate lunch or a pop-up dinner party, while this former cathedral can be turned into a formal dining hall with the right furniture and table settings. Or, maybe you’d prefer a stylish whiskey bar venue?

What if we told you that these spaces were all available at the same Peerspace location — and can be booked together or separately? No matter what kind of occasion you have in mind, the Peerspace Concierge can help you line up the perfect caterer and venue for it.

4. Serve fresh pizzas made by Wood Fired Flatbreads

Choosing the right catering menu can be a difficult decision, especially if you have any dietary preferences to account for. Wood Fired Flatbreads takes some of the pressure off by allowing your guests to choose from several pizza options cooked in a mobile pizza oven. Not only is fresh pizza the perfect crowd-pleaser, but Wood Fired Flatbreads says that they can cook a pizza every 90 seconds, keeping up with even a large and hungry crowd.

Prices vary based on which package you choose. They all include unlimited pizza but provide a different combination of specialty toppings. You can also request a gluten-free option, as well as side salads and desserts, such as the Nutella dessert pizza and an Italian soda bar.

5. Build a custom buffet with Cooked Goose Catering

Cooked Goose is another well-known caterer in Pittsburgh with over 35 years in business. They serve the entire tri-state area, and offer a variety of options, including full-service catering and a build- your-own-buffet option. From breakfast and brunch buffets, to boxed sandwiches, you can choose hot or cold food for corporate events, picnics, weddings, and more. They also offer fruit platters, coffee, and dessert, making them suitable for a single meal or multi-course menu.

Also, don’t miss their holiday menus, which are fully prepared and just need to be reheated and served. These include a Holiday Feast and a Prime Rib Special that you can pick up and serve at any Peerspace venue with a kitchen and dining room. It’s no surprise they’re among the best caterers in Pittsburgh!

6. Throw a summer party with Kimberley Ashlee

Among top caterers in Pittsburgh, Kimberley Ashlee offers a hip, modern vibe that’s perfect for a pop-up dinner or backyard party. With seasonal menus created from scratch, as well as a sommelier and mixologist on hand to design a custom cocktail or wine pairing, both your food and drink options will be taken care of.

From formal weddings to casual social events, Kimberley Ashlee has experience working at a range of venues, and can even bring a food truck to your outdoor event space. Plus, they offer customized options for any dietary requirement — such as a vegan, gluten-free pasta bar!

7. Enjoy a classic BBQ with the Pittsburgh Barbecue Company

Our next pick for a caterer in Pittsburgh is the Pittsburgh Barbecue Company, which is exactly what it sounds like! Choose this caterer for a classic menu serving North Carolina-style BBQ, including sides like hickory baked beans, macaroni salad, and coleslaw. They offer packages intended for a minimum of 20 people, with prices based on the number of meats you choose, such as smoked brisket, pulled pork, smoked chicken, or classic hot dogs and hamburgers.

And if you think that barbecue is strictly for casual events, that’s not the case here. If you want to host a sit-down meal, they offer full-service catering with linens and tableware provided.

8. Snack on popcorn with the Pittsburgh Popcorn Company

Last but not least, don’t forget snacks! While many of these caterers in Pittsburgh do offer dessert options, sometimes you want something a little more unique. The Pittsburgh Popcorn Company offers several catering options, including a popcorn bar and custom-printed tins.

With a popcorn bar, your guests can choose from several different flavors, including real Wisconsin cheddar and peanut butter cup, and mix-and-match their own bag of popcorn. If you choose custom tins, you can give each guest a souvenir with your wedding date or company logo on it.

You won’t find any shortage of caterers in Pittsburgh to choose from. The hardest part may be choosing just one! Whether you’re hosting an intimate dinner for a small group or a backyard BBQ for a large crowd, browse Peerspace to find the perfect venue for your event. Once you do, call up the Concierge service to make sure you have everything you need taken care of, including any special catering requests or equipment rentals you have in mind!

Find unique event venues in Pittsburgh on Peerspace