36 Best Mansions for Rent in Water Mill, NY | Peerspace

Why Peerspace?

Unique spaces

Every day we uncover new, creative spaces — from neighborhood galleries to hidden rooftops, and beyond.

Honest pricing

Our spaces are priced to fit your budget. Pay by the hour without worrying about hidden fees.

Smooth bookings

No more messy contracts. We build the tools to make booking a space as easy as the click of a button.

Popular mansions

House "Living Room" Located in Orange

City of Orange, NJ

5.0 (1)

25 guests

From

$75

/hr

2 hr min

Estate garden outside NYC

50 guests

From

$200

/hr

8 hr min

Your Urban Castle Awaits!

East Orange, NJ

50 guests

From

$200

/hr

4 hr min

Historic Colonial Home For Rent In Forest Hills

Forest Hill, Newark, NJ

4.0 (2)

65 guests

From

$195

/hr

3 hr min

New Yorks ONLY Modern Black Mansion

Shore Acres, Staten Island, NY

5.0 (7)

30 guests

From

$500

/hr

4 hr min

Historic Mansion with Pool for Film & Photo

Mariners Harbor, New York, NY

5.0 (20)

100 guests

From

$325

/hr

8 hr min

Elegantly preserved, traditional Harlem Townhouse!

Central Harlem, New York, NY

5.0 (11)

100 guests

From

$250

/hr

5 hr min

Italian Mansion in Riverdale with bomb shelter

West Bronx, New York, NY

4.9 (30)

20 guests

From

$250

/hr

3 hr min

Historic Federal Colonial with Wraparound porch in Gas Lamp town of Glen Ridge, 12 miles from New York City.

50 guests

From

$395

/hr

4 hr min

Double Island Kitchen & White Columned House on 2 Wooded Acres, with Stone Bridge

Llewellyn Park, West Orange, NJ

50 guests

From

$250

/hr

5 hr min

Luxe Manhattan Madison Avenue Greystone Mansion

Midtown Manhattan, New York, NY

4.8 (5)

12 guests

From

$380

/hr

10 hr min

Newly Renovated & Luxurious Historic Home with Large Garden and Free OnSite Parking in Beautiful Neighborhood of Brooklyn

Kensington, Brooklyn, NY

5.0 (1)

50 guests

From

$495

/hr

6 hr min

Suburban Queen Ann Victorian home 13 miles outside of NYC

City of Orange, NJ

4.9 (25)

50 guests

From

$125

/hr

4 hr min

White Victorian Home

Westerleigh, Staten Island, NY

5.0 (10)

20 guests

From

$175

/hr

4 hr min

Upscale Victorian Home

Rockaway Beach, NY

40 guests

From

$420

/hr

4 hr min

Large House In A Historical Neighborhood On A Beautiful Street

Forest Hill, Newark, NJ

40 guests

From

$150

/hr

4 hr min

Grand Home on the Bay

Rockaway Park, NY

5.0 (1)

75 guests

From

$600

/hr

4 hr min

Elevated Luxury Living with Sweeping NYC Skyline Views

Upper Montclair, NJ

20 guests

From

$200

/hr

5 hr min

Large Space at elegant CASA MONOCERUS

Harlem, New York, NY

4.9 (12)

25 guests

From

$100

/hr

1 hr min

Charming Lenox Hill Uptown Home | 3-Room Production Suite – Kitchen, Dining & Steinway Piano

Lenox Hill, Manhattan, NY

4.8 (95)

100 guests

From

$300

/hr

2 hr min

Buckingham HOUSE

Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY

250 guests

From

$600

/hr

10 hr min

Grand Waterfront Home

100 guests

From

$650

/hr

4 hr min

Opulent Ballroom in UWS

Manhattan Valley, NEW YORK, NY

163 guests

From

$350

/hr

4 hr min

Bright, Airy, Charming House near Prospect Park

Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY

5.0 (5)

30 guests

From

$550

/hr

8 hr min

Grand Ballroom located uptown in Harlem, New York.

Harlem, New York, NY

5.0 (1)

500 guests

From

$800

/hr

4 hr min

Historic Neighborhood Victorian House

Park Hill, Yonkers, NY

30 guests

From

$150

/hr

3 hr min

Italian Baroque Upper East Side Mansion

Upper East Side, New York, NY

60 guests

From

$2,000

/hr

2 hr min

Luxurious Beachfront Mansion with Outstanding Views, Private Beach, and more!

Sands Point, NY

5.0 (5)

50 guests

From

$600

/hr

4 hr min

Spacious and airy, classic downtown with elegant and funky decor.

Lower Manhattan, New York, NY

50 guests

From

$300

/hr

3 hr min

Historic Brooklyn Brownstone Full of Original Details

Crown Heights, Brooklyn, NY

5.0 (30)

20 guests

From

$185

/hr

2 hr min

Editorial Waterfront Estate with Pool, Greenhouse & Private Beach

North Hempstead, Port Washington, NY

40 guests

From

$600

/hr

1 hr min

Parisian Mansion near NYC with Indoor & Outdoor Swimming Pool

5.0 (6)

200 guests

From

$799

/hr

2 hr min

Opulent Beach House

Belle Harbor, NY

50 guests

From

$1,000

/hr

4 hr min

Brooklyn Single Family Victorian

Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY

45 guests

From

$475

/hr

4 hr min

Ditmas Park Victorian House with Front and Back Yards

Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY

5.0 (1)

50 guests

From

$400

/hr

2 hr min

Modern Family Home

50 guests

From

$450

/hr

4 hr min

Similar searches in Water Mill, NY

Similar searches

Daylight Studio

Nearby locations

Bridgehampton, NY

Southampton, NY

East Hampton, NY

Hampton Bays, NY

East Marion, NY

Westhampton, NY

Updated October 25, 2026Our data is refreshed in real time using booking trends, verified guest reviews, and direct partner updates — with additional quality checks from our team.