Rent a birthday party venue in Bay Shore, NY

Discover thousands of unique birthday party venues for rent perfect for your event.

Enter your activity
Bay Shore, NY, United States

How birthday celebration venues work on Peerspace

Peerspace is the easiest way to book unique venues for birthday parties. We also have spaces for productions and meetings.

Discover Spaces

Unique venues

Every day we uncover new, creative spaces perfect for your birthday celebration — from neighborhood galleries to hidden rooftops, and beyond.

Honest pricing

Our spaces are priced to fit your budget. Hire by the hour for your birthday party without worrying about hidden fees.

Smooth bookings

No more messy contracts. We build the tools to make hiring out a space for your birthday celebration as easy as the click of a button.

Popular birthday party venues

Explore all of our birthday party venues in Bay Shore. See All ›

Frequently Asked Questions

Pricing and popularity information in this section is based on proprietary Peerspace booking data, reflecting recent booking activity and the latest data available through March 2026.

How much does a birthday party venue cost to rent in Bay Shore?

Birthday party venues in Bay Shore average $47 per hour to rent, but it’s easy to spend less or more depending on what you’re looking for. For a space on the smaller side, expect to spend closer to $124, whereas larger venues run about $409 per hour.

What's the best day to rent a birthday party venue in Bay Shore?

Saturdays are the most popular day for booking birthday party venues in Bay Shore.

How popular are birthday party venues in Bay Shore?

Our local hosts have welcomed 129 people into their birthday party venues with reviews averaging 5 stars. Most even said they would book again -- about 91%.

How long do people rent birthday party venues in Bay Shore?

Most birthday party venues are scheduled for 2 hours, with 12 people in attendance. You’ll find the most Birthday Parties starting between 4:00 PM and 5:00 PM.

Reviews for birthday party venues

Darwin A.
Beautiful Event Hall
The party was a success!! The space gave us more then enough room to enjoy our son's 1st birthday party. The staff was amazing in helping us out, we would definitely book again...
Mimoona A.
Parker Green Space
Beautiful and spacious location. Comfortably accommodated all guests and the host went above and beyond to make our “surprise “ birthday party a success. I would definitely rent this space again and highly recommend it to anyone looking to have an outdoor event...
Christina A.
Theater, Entertainment, Retro Arcade, Billard, Ping pong, poker, Games, Parties
of my questions, and was very accommodating. The space appeared as advertised, even looked a little bigger in person! My friends and I celebrated my birthday with a game themed night, jeopardy on the projector, and use of the host's game options! Thank you again to the...
Sheena A.
Queens Art Studio & Outdoor Yard
yumi was so much fun and welcoming , the spot was beautiful and felt like home. i enjoyed my birthday party and would recommend this spot to anyone. and the price was definitely unbeatable...
Gingee B.
Gorgeous Spacious Industrial Loft Space
hosted a 40th birthday party here this past weekend. Jon, Shannon and Michelle were wonderful and accommodating. This space is an absolute gem! With a beautiful, open floor plan and high ceilings, it leaves you with the feel of a Manhattan loft. My guests were both shocked and...
Leah B.
Garden City's Events & Birthday/Showers Loft
The space was perfect for my sisters 40th birthday party! Thank you for having us
Chyna C.
Center of Long Island Private Party Loft
needs !! Was extremely friendly! The venue itself was extremely spacious, beautiful lighting, just over all amazing & a wonderful booking for my daughters first birthday party!! Can’t thank you enough...
Stephanie C.
Creative and Fitness Studio in Long Island
Had my themed birthday party here. Brittany was amazing she was super helpful, provided chair and tables and was awesome to work with. This spot is big clean and perfect for any type of event. Would 10000% book again and recommend to anyone I know...
Christina D.
Events On The Main Venue with amazing private yard space
Events on the Main is the best! Bryanna and her team helped make my sons 1st birthday party very special. If you are looking for a nice indoor/outdoor venue, this is the place. I will definitely be back! Thanks again Bryanna...
Iranthi D.
Open-Concept Modern Club Room with Spacious Kitchen
Hosted a birthday party. Venue was great. Summer party would be amazing with the view
Debra E.
Creative Canvas - Private Outdoor Space (Perfect for Brunch, BBQ, Baby Showers, Date/Movie Night, Fundraisers and More)
We recently rented omi's backyard for our child's first birthday party, and it was an outstanding experience from start to finish. The backyard is humongous, providing a great sense of space and allowing you to create whatever look you're going for. While our event was...
Celeste F.
Theater, Entertainment, Retro Arcade, Billard, Ping pong, poker, Games, Parties
my friends and I to move around comfortably. We enjoyed our time so much, tons of entertainment and perfect space to throw a birthday party. I would book again! Raul was also very nice and made sure we were fine throughout the night...
Jessica H.
Brand New Boutique Event Space, Williston Park
This space was so perfect for my little one year old’s birthday party! Eric was so pleasant to converse with in the process of booking this space as well...
Kayla J.
Creative and Fitness Studio in Long Island
threw a 21st birthday party for 20 people at this place and it was the perfect space! It was super clean, big, and had LED lights which is what I really wanted. I could also play my own music through the speaker that was provided. It’s perfect...
Jerry K.
Theater, Entertainment, Retro Arcade, Billard, Ping pong, poker, Games, Parties
Place is cool and clean. Raul is a fantastic host with many gadgets and tech. Fun place to be and celebrate a birthday...
Nyasia M.
Empty Studio in Residential Neighborhood with Natural Light
This space was beautiful and perfect for my son’s 1st birthday party. Yona was super helpful and attentive to all my needs. She answered all my questions and was very friendly. The space was clean and easy for my guests to find as well. Very happy with...
Margherita M.
Backyard Retreat & Cottage
June 7th we hosted my friends birthday party in this backyard. We had the best time, the pool was amazing , she provided tables for us to put all of our food and belongings . The cottage was so cute and provided a fridge which was super helpful. We overall...
Robby M.
Theater, Entertainment, Retro Arcade, Billard, Ping pong, poker, Games, Parties
The venue looks even more cool and lively in person. The space itself was organized, clean, and so intricate in all the details. Celebrated a birthday here with about 10 people and there was tons of space and things to do. A floor to ceiling projector and gaming...
Brandon P.
Garden City's Events & Birthday/Showers Loft
planned my wife’s surprise 30th birthday party at the Loft, and it could not have gone any better. Mirv and Christina were so friendly and easy to work with. And the space itself has so much character. We fit ~40 people comfortably but it still was very...
Jessica Z.
Charming multi-use Space
that was perfect for my son’s first birthday. The staff is super friendly and helpful and made a huge impact on our experience. My family complimented on how nice it is and I would definitely host a party here again...
Updated February 26, 2026Our data is refreshed in real time using booking trends, verified guest reviews, and direct partner updates — with additional quality checks from our team.